Showing posts with label All terrain bike. Show all posts
Showing posts with label All terrain bike. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 24, 2024

What's In A Name?

Video image grab from THIS YouTube video.
 NOTE: Large doses of "my opinion" will be handed out in gloppy dollops today. You've been forewarned.....

Recently at Eurobike Scott Bicycles had a little surprise that was posted on a couple websites. This bicycle is interesting for one reason only. It is notable because of what Scott called the bike. The Scott Scale GR. (GR = "Gravel")

The bike caused an immediate uproar in the comment sections wherever it has been written about. Folks are arguing about what it is and how it should or should not be used. 

Look - this is all about names. That is all. It has absolutely zero to do with riding the bike the name is slapped on. We only have ourselves to blame for all of this nonsense. How certain bicycles came to be known in a general sense has done more to cause confusion, disruption, and unnecessary arguments than anything else about cycling has in the past or present.

Remember when these were called "snow bikes"?

One of the best and most rare examples of where a bicycle was named incorrectly and subsequently was renamed was when the fat bikes were first introduced in mass retail as "snow bikes". 

The name made sense because, at the time, fat bikes were revolutionizing Winter riding. However; consumers weren't getting the idea that Winter riding was "fun" and were relying on their shallow take, which was, 'bicycles were not ever ridden in Winter' and "Who would want to do that anyway?" The bike was discounted as a non-viable choice before a test ride could be offered. 

Retailers very quickly moved to "fat bike" to describe the corpulent-tired bicycles and focused on capability, fun, and stability as the message. And "...oh yeah, you can ride these in Winter if you want as well." This put the correct idea in the heads of many consumers and the fat bike revolution took off for a while there. Had we stuck with "snow bike" the amount of bikes sold would have been far, far less than what has been sold. 

And to the fat bike's benefit, the name it was finally saddled with did not describe where you rode it, which - in my opinion - is probably a good thing. Names matter. Words have power. Naming your bike a "snow bike" or a "fat bike" does different things in the mind of a human being. So too does "gravel bike". This is where the Scott Scale GR comes back into the story here. 

The Scott Scale GR obviously comes from a completely different evolutionary line of bicycles than does your typical "gravel bike". It doesn't take a genius to see that it is an XC racing MTB with a rigid fork that has "adventure nipples" attached to its legs. Scott can call their bicycles whatever they want as far as trademark law is not violated. And why wouldn't they call it a "gravel bike"? It is one of the hottest categories in cycling. Especially when one of their own has stated that they like using a MTB for gravel riding. 

Originally called "all-terrain bikes", these became known as MTB's.

So, what the heck is it anyway? Well, to answer that question, we have to go all the way back into early mountain bike (MTB) history when a company called "Mountain Bikes" existed. 

Yes, the term was a brand name. All other bikes of its ilk were known as "all-terrain bikes". However; the brand "Mountain Bikes", started by fat tire pioneers Gary Fisher and Charlie Kelly, had too cool a name for just one brand to "own it" and suddenly everyone was calling their "all-terrain bikes" Mountain Bikes. Soon to be abbreviated to "MTB". 

Once again, a bad choice. Had "all-terrain" stuck instead of mountain bike, we maybe would have seen an even wider adoption of fat-tired 26" wheeled bikes across the nation, not just where there were mountains, or where younginz thought they could do "mountain bike things". Had all-terrain stuck I think "all-road" would have followed. But "gravel" got stuck to this drop-bar, all roads type of bike and so, well...... What the heck does "gravel" even mean? 

Getting back to the Scott bicycle. It is really an "all-terrain' bike, but yeah.... Good luck with that! It will never be known as that and people will attach "gravel" to a bike these days just because it gets the eyeballs and the comment sections going. Mountain bike? That would have done little to attract any attention. Scott marketers did exactly what a good marketing department should do. Use a name that gets attention. Whether that makes sense or not doesn't really matter.

Thursday, February 24, 2022

What's In A Name?

1980's Mongoose All Terrain Pro- An example of when the name was different
 Recently I noted an article on "Bikepacking.com" where they had posted concerning the naming of a certain fat tired type of bicycle. In this case, they favor the term "ATB " over that of "Mountain Bike". Their feeling that the term 'mountain bike' denotes a certain riding style and that bikepacking denotes another style which is better represented by another name, which was used early on in the off-road, 26"er days. 

That acronym, "ATB", stands for "All Terrain Bicycle". Those early bicycles built by Tom Ritchey, Joe Breeze, and others were not "mountain bikes". Not originally. That term was a brand name first, (MountainBikes) not a name for all off-road, fat tired bicycles. But then it changed. Riders and media bought into calling these bikes "mountain bikes", and by the late 80's, "All Terrain Bicycles" was too burdensome and too pushed out of the mindset of consumers to ever be brought back. Or was it? 

Riding off-road, in the Mid-West, NOT on mountains.

In one manner of thinking about this, you can ride single track all across the nation, but not all of it is on mountains, right? So it would make sense to call such bicycles "All Terrain Bicycles", from that point of view. However; then where do you draw the line. I mean, you can ride a fat bike on single track anywhere, yes? That said, most of what I am seeing in that linked article is saying those bikes are not "ATB"'s in their minds. 

That "Bikepacking.com" article takes a swipe at "gravel bikes" as well, which- as you long-time readers know- is a category I have said for years is misnamed. But you know what? The marketing departments got a hold of it and now there is no turning back. In fact, marketing wonks have maybe gone a bit too far and are now off the deep end.

I do agree with the premise of the "Bikepacking.com" article though. I feel much the same way about adopting the term "ATB" for those off-road, fat tired bikes, including fat bikes. Is it a better, all-inclusive description for those bikes than "mountain bike"? Undoubtedly. But does that name, "ATB", conjure up the same imagery in your mind, and similar feelings as the term "mountain bike" does? No..... I think "ATB" is a very bland acronym for fat tired, go anywhere without a road bike, bike. It just doesn't have any cache'. It is kind of soulless. So, yeah.....good luck with that, Bikepacking.com. I just don't see that happening for the niche of cycling that you represent. 

And that brings up another point: Numbers. The industry, if it sees sales, backs up that with an outpouring of marketing, product, and R&D. Resources are scarce in the cycling industry. Whatever is tickling the consumer's fancy gets the attention. Right now, it is the "gravel category". Back in the 1980's/90's it was mountain biking. Not "ATB-ing". That sounded lame-o, and it just was not as marketable as 'mountain biking' was. Same thing with 'gravel riding', (or the even more hated term "gravel grinding"). It got tagged onto this category of bike and style of riding, and it took off. Do you think marketing folks thought the name was stupid? (I know many did) Do you think they were about to change the name and potentially harm the flow of money coming from the many people who were interested in this form of cycling? Not in a million years! So, 'gravel' it was, and back in the 80's, the same thing occurred. The common folks adopted the term "mountain bike" and the marketing departments ran with it.

Now MTB is so fractured into sub-cultures and styles that you're never going to get around that name that form of cycling gained back then. A certain sub-set of a niche in bikepacking may take to that name "ATB", but many sub-sets of "mountain biking" have their own names for their bikes as well. Which was pointed out in the piece by "Bikepacking.com", ironically. Why should "ATB" be any different in that regard? 

Tradition may play a part in this. Here you are trying to re-name an already established bike and activity.  What the proponents of the modern-day ATB are pushing was done in 1980. Those riders were mainly doing off-pavement, trail-touring. That became "mountain biking". When you pedaled out back with your panniers and fat tires, that's what you were doing. Not "ATB-ing". That is why it will be hard to turn the name around for these bikes. If anything, "bikepacking bikes" has a much better chance at becoming entrenched in the minds of cyclists now than "ATB" does.

But, I could be wrong here. I'd love it if I were, because I'd ditch the name 'gravel' for this form of cycling I love in a heartbeat.

What's In A Name?

1980's Mongoose All Terrain Pro- An example of when the name was different
 Recently I noted an article on "Bikepacking.com" where they had posted concerning the naming of a certain fat tired type of bicycle. In this case, they favor the term "ATB " over that of "Mountain Bike". Their feeling that the term 'mountain bike' denotes a certain riding style and that bikepacking denotes another style which is better represented by another name, which was used early on in the off-road, 26"er days. 

That acronym, "ATB", stands for "All Terrain Bicycle". Those early bicycles built by Tom Ritchey, Joe Breeze, and others were not "mountain bikes". Not originally. That term was a brand name first, (MountainBikes) not a name for all off-road, fat tired bicycles. But then it changed. Riders and media bought into calling these bikes "mountain bikes", and by the late 80's, "All Terrain Bicycles" was too burdensome and too pushed out of the mindset of consumers to ever be brought back. Or was it? 

Riding off-road, in the Mid-West, NOT on mountains.

In one manner of thinking about this, you can ride single track all across the nation, but not all of it is on mountains, right? So it would make sense to call such bicycles "All Terrain Bicycles", from that point of view. However; then where do you draw the line. I mean, you can ride a fat bike on single track anywhere, yes? That said, most of what I am seeing in that linked article is saying those bikes are not "ATB"'s in their minds. 

That "Bikepacking.com" article takes a swipe at "gravel bikes" as well, which- as you long-time readers know- is a category I have said for years is misnamed. But you know what? The marketing departments got a hold of it and now there is no turning back. In fact, marketing wonks have maybe gone a bit too far and are now off the deep end.

I do agree with the premise of the "Bikepacking.com" article though. I feel much the same way about adopting the term "ATB" for those off-road, fat tired bikes, including fat bikes. Is it a better, all-inclusive description for those bikes than "mountain bike"? Undoubtedly. But does that name, "ATB", conjure up the same imagery in your mind, and similar feelings as the term "mountain bike" does? No..... I think "ATB" is a very bland acronym for fat tired, go anywhere without a road bike, bike. It just doesn't have any cache'. It is kind of soulless. So, yeah.....good luck with that, Bikepacking.com. I just don't see that happening for the niche of cycling that you represent. 

And that brings up another point: Numbers. The industry, if it sees sales, backs up that with an outpouring of marketing, product, and R&D. Resources are scarce in the cycling industry. Whatever is tickling the consumer's fancy gets the attention. Right now, it is the "gravel category". Back in the 1980's/90's it was mountain biking. Not "ATB-ing". That sounded lame-o, and it just was not as marketable as 'mountain biking' was. Same thing with 'gravel riding', (or the even more hated term "gravel grinding"). It got tagged onto this category of bike and style of riding, and it took off. Do you think marketing folks thought the name was stupid? (I know many did) Do you think they were about to change the name and potentially harm the flow of money coming from the many people who were interested in this form of cycling? Not in a million years! So, 'gravel' it was, and back in the 80's, the same thing occurred. The common folks adopted the term "mountain bike" and the marketing departments ran with it.

Now MTB is so fractured into sub-cultures and styles that you're never going to get around that name that form of cycling gained back then. A certain sub-set of a niche in bikepacking may take to that name "ATB", but many sub-sets of "mountain biking" have their own names for their bikes as well. Which was pointed out in the piece by "Bikepacking.com", ironically. Why should "ATB" be any different in that regard? 

Tradition may play a part in this. Here you are trying to re-name an already established bike and activity.  What the proponents of the modern-day ATB are pushing was done in 1980. Those riders were mainly doing off-pavement, trail-touring. That became "mountain biking". When you pedaled out back with your panniers and fat tires, that's what you were doing. Not "ATB-ing". That is why it will be hard to turn the name around for these bikes. If anything, "bikepacking bikes" has a much better chance at becoming entrenched in the minds of cyclists now than "ATB" does.

But, I could be wrong here. I'd love it if I were, because I'd ditch the name 'gravel' for this form of cycling I love in a heartbeat.

Thursday, August 13, 2020

How About "ATRB"?

 

First of all- the internet is up at "Guitar Ted Productions" again. WooHoo! Although I suppose I could have used my iPhone as a 'hotspot', as a couple of you suggested, what you didn't know was that my phone does not work in the house without WiFi. Like, barely at all. This is why I have to get away from the G-Ted Headquarters to get a decent enough signal to do anything. And by the way, it's been like that for years no matter what phone I had. I can recall many times having to stand outside on a cold January evening just to be able to chat with someone. An anomaly of this house or something.... anyway. 

That's enough about that! What I really wanted to share today is about a name. Now, I completely understand that this ship has sailed. Marketing has fully entrenched the idea that the word 'gravel' attached to any marketing spiel is gold. The category is off the rails and fully built into the vernacular of cyclists. There is, as they say, no turning back. 

So, what I have in mind doesn't matter anymore. But I'm throwing it out there regardless. Just as an aside, I may or may not have already mentioned this name.........back in 2012, when it mattered, but the term "gravel" took off anyway, despite my voiced misgivings about the name and the perceptions it engenders. Water over the dam now.....

So, I was riding to work, there is this section of old trolley car trail, part of an old inter-urban railway system here that was, regrettably, left to die because of cars, of course. This old remaining section of the inter-urban railway is now a narrow pea gravel and dirt trail that hugs the side of a low bluff near the Cedar River. As I was pedaling up a grade on the Noble GX5 with the FLO Cycling G700 wheels, I thought about how this bike looks, at first glance, like some weird Pro racer's rig with a frame bag or two, and how most people probably are amazed that a 'road bike' is doing this sort of rustic, rough track with no issues. Then it dawned on me. 

This bike is a "ATRB". It is, for all intents and purposes, an 'all terrain road bike'. It just makes perfect sense. But, yeah........ Too late to turn the ship back to port now.


How About "ATRB"?

 

First of all- the internet is up at "Guitar Ted Productions" again. WooHoo! Although I suppose I could have used my iPhone as a 'hotspot', as a couple of you suggested, what you didn't know was that my phone does not work in the house without WiFi. Like, barely at all. This is why I have to get away from the G-Ted Headquarters to get a decent enough signal to do anything. And by the way, it's been like that for years no matter what phone I had. I can recall many times having to stand outside on a cold January evening just to be able to chat with someone. An anomaly of this house or something.... anyway. 

That's enough about that! What I really wanted to share today is about a name. Now, I completely understand that this ship has sailed. Marketing has fully entrenched the idea that the word 'gravel' attached to any marketing spiel is gold. The category is off the rails and fully built into the vernacular of cyclists. There is, as they say, no turning back. 

So, what I have in mind doesn't matter anymore. But I'm throwing it out there regardless. Just as an aside, I may or may not have already mentioned this name.........back in 2012, when it mattered, but the term "gravel" took off anyway, despite my voiced misgivings about the name and the perceptions it engenders. Water over the dam now.....

So, I was riding to work, there is this section of old trolley car trail, part of an old inter-urban railway system here that was, regrettably, left to die because of cars, of course. This old remaining section of the inter-urban railway is now a narrow pea gravel and dirt trail that hugs the side of a low bluff near the Cedar River. As I was pedaling up a grade on the Noble GX5 with the FLO Cycling G700 wheels, I thought about how this bike looks, at first glance, like some weird Pro racer's rig with a frame bag or two, and how most people probably are amazed that a 'road bike' is doing this sort of rustic, rough track with no issues. Then it dawned on me. 

This bike is a "ATRB". It is, for all intents and purposes, an 'all terrain road bike'. It just makes perfect sense. But, yeah........ Too late to turn the ship back to port now.


Thursday, July 28, 2011

The Ultimate All-Terrain Vehicle?

A Cool B Road On The 2011 GTDRI Course
On Wednesday, I needed to do some final checking on a potentially closed B Road in Tama County that is part of the Guitar Ted Death Ride Invitational that happens this Saturday.

I decided to take the Snow Dog for the job. Yes- a fat bike. I have an idea that the fat bike might be the best for B Road explorations since B Roads in Iowa can present certain difficulties that normal gravel road riding doesn't. Things like ruts, for example. And not just any ol' ruts either.

Another reason I took it was because I might have run into some wet areas, (I didn't), and my thought was to test the bigger tires on the sticky clay. I still have not gotten to do that yet, but that day will come. I did get into some sticky wet gravel the last time I went down this way, and those bulbous tires did alright. Sure did.

What I didn't think of was silty dust and sand. Yes, I did run across this and the fat tires were great on it. The best part was that I left minimal impact on the road. Only the little Larry tread block pattern, and nothing more was left by my passing. The next decent gust of wind will hide that in a heart beat. Cool!

Wild Flowers In Tama County

What is striking me about having the Mukluk is that this just might be the "true all-terrain bike". While it isn't fast, nimble, or probably a choice many would consider at first, (I know I didn't), I think people would be pleasantly surprised by the format's capabilities. While I have not done this, my friend Ben Witt says that the fat bike tires do really well on big rocky terrain where one would normally think of a full suspension mountain bike.

I do know that places I thought were "off-limits" due to the difficulty in traversing over the terrain are now sought out because of the fat bike. The floatation of the tires, and bump absorbing qualities come in handy.....most of the time.

Sure, the tires and wheels are heavy, and the steering is a bit sluggish, but with the right attitude, one can climb stuff, go over stuff, and have more fun on terrain that challenges a "normal" mountain bike, or stops them dead in their tracks. You work harder going up, but not that much harder. You just gear down, and crawl, instead of powering over,or getting knocked off-line, perhaps. I don't quite know how to put it other than you have to ride these with a whole different attitude than a normal mountain bike, or cross bike on gravel, B Roads, and where ever else you fancy going. That sand bar along the river? You bet. Got a mud bog to cross to get to the other side? Go for it. Snow? Well.....of course!

A Barn For Jason B
 And About That Course: Yeah, well I got turned around and lost for awhile yesterday. (Remember my post about Adventure?) It turned out okay, but in the process I found a stunning gravel road that with a bit of re-routing would be a great addition to the GTDRI course. So.....I'm changing the cues again! 

I'm sorry, but this road is worth it.  It eliminates a chunk of boring, narrow paved blacktop. It climbs the same ridge, but does so in a more serpentine, interesting, and rustic way on gravel. Plus, if we are as lucky as I was Wednesday, we'll spy a zebra. Yes- an honest to goodness zebra. It eliminates about a half mile of pavement overall too. (Well, more if you count riding on the shoulder, and we're going to.)  The downside? We'll have to ride on the shoulder of HWY 63 for a mile and a half north out of Toledo. It is a wide, gravel shoulder though, so it shouldn't be an issue.

I've got people coming from Michigan for the ride even! Talk about floored. It will be fun to see everyone that shows up. I can't wait. And no.....I won't be riding the Mukluk! (Although it would be better on the B Roads!)

The Ultimate All-Terrain Vehicle?

A Cool B Road On The 2011 GTDRI Course
On Wednesday, I needed to do some final checking on a potentially closed B Road in Tama County that is part of the Guitar Ted Death Ride Invitational that happens this Saturday.

I decided to take the Snow Dog for the job. Yes- a fat bike. I have an idea that the fat bike might be the best for B Road explorations since B Roads in Iowa can present certain difficulties that normal gravel road riding doesn't. Things like ruts, for example. And not just any ol' ruts either.

Another reason I took it was because I might have run into some wet areas, (I didn't), and my thought was to test the bigger tires on the sticky clay. I still have not gotten to do that yet, but that day will come. I did get into some sticky wet gravel the last time I went down this way, and those bulbous tires did alright. Sure did.

What I didn't think of was silty dust and sand. Yes, I did run across this and the fat tires were great on it. The best part was that I left minimal impact on the road. Only the little Larry tread block pattern, and nothing more was left by my passing. The next decent gust of wind will hide that in a heart beat. Cool!

Wild Flowers In Tama County

What is striking me about having the Mukluk is that this just might be the "true all-terrain bike". While it isn't fast, nimble, or probably a choice many would consider at first, (I know I didn't), I think people would be pleasantly surprised by the format's capabilities. While I have not done this, my friend Ben Witt says that the fat bike tires do really well on big rocky terrain where one would normally think of a full suspension mountain bike.

I do know that places I thought were "off-limits" due to the difficulty in traversing over the terrain are now sought out because of the fat bike. The floatation of the tires, and bump absorbing qualities come in handy.....most of the time.

Sure, the tires and wheels are heavy, and the steering is a bit sluggish, but with the right attitude, one can climb stuff, go over stuff, and have more fun on terrain that challenges a "normal" mountain bike, or stops them dead in their tracks. You work harder going up, but not that much harder. You just gear down, and crawl, instead of powering over,or getting knocked off-line, perhaps. I don't quite know how to put it other than you have to ride these with a whole different attitude than a normal mountain bike, or cross bike on gravel, B Roads, and where ever else you fancy going. That sand bar along the river? You bet. Got a mud bog to cross to get to the other side? Go for it. Snow? Well.....of course!

A Barn For Jason B
 And About That Course: Yeah, well I got turned around and lost for awhile yesterday. (Remember my post about Adventure?) It turned out okay, but in the process I found a stunning gravel road that with a bit of re-routing would be a great addition to the GTDRI course. So.....I'm changing the cues again! 

I'm sorry, but this road is worth it.  It eliminates a chunk of boring, narrow paved blacktop. It climbs the same ridge, but does so in a more serpentine, interesting, and rustic way on gravel. Plus, if we are as lucky as I was Wednesday, we'll spy a zebra. Yes- an honest to goodness zebra. It eliminates about a half mile of pavement overall too. (Well, more if you count riding on the shoulder, and we're going to.)  The downside? We'll have to ride on the shoulder of HWY 63 for a mile and a half north out of Toledo. It is a wide, gravel shoulder though, so it shouldn't be an issue.

I've got people coming from Michigan for the ride even! Talk about floored. It will be fun to see everyone that shows up. I can't wait. And no.....I won't be riding the Mukluk! (Although it would be better on the B Roads!)