NOTICE: The Guitar Ted 'Lube-Off' is a comparison of different lubrication products for bicycle chains that is undertaken in 'real world' conditions in a set way. Then I compare and contrast the results with past 'Lube-Off' products to see "which one is best for me". This is done for entertainment purposes and the reader should apply their own reasoning and discernment while reading my 'Lube-Off' entries. What works for me may not work for you at all.
NOTE: Stan's sent over a bottle of their Polar Drip Wax to Guitar Ted Productions at no charge for test and review purposes. Stan's is not bribing or paying Guitar Ted for this review. All opinions are Guitar Ted's.
Okay, I have a little housekeeping to do before we dive into this update on the new Stan's Polar Drip Wax lubricant. In a FN&V recently I stated I tried to remain independent from lubricant manufacturers by buying all my testing samples. This is in error because I forgot about this Stan's lube and Stan's previous BioBased Dry Lube I tested last year. Both were samples sent to me at no charge. So, I wanted you to understand this and assure you, dear readers, that I hold the Stan's lubes to the same standards as I would any other lube.
I just wanted to clarify this point. Now, on with the update......
Update #2:
With Stan's having sent the Polar Drip Wax ahead of the release date, I was able to ride this lube some amount beforehand. (Intro seen HERE in case you missed it) Since then I have been able to put in more miles but specifically I was able to get in some really demanding conditions.
The recent Labor Day ride with N.Y. Roll featured several miles of dry dirt road with a fair amount of loose dirt on top of hard pack. For instance, when I was trailing N.Y. Roll I could see a small cloud of dirt/dust being generated off his tires. This was bathing our chains in a constant bath of dry dirt. The gravel sections were also very dusty in parts of the course.
| One example of the many dirt road miles we experienced |
I knew this would be a very severe test of Stan's Polar Drip Wax. Stan's claims up to around 200 miles between applications. However; with all the bathing in dirt and dust during my most recent ride, I have decided it is already time to clean and re-apply the Stan's Polar Drip Wax.
I felt the chain was at its limit from a lube perspective. The rollers are feeling dry, but there are no sounds of squeaking or grinding when I checked the chain immediately after the ride. After a wipe-down, I felt the chain still had some coating of wax on it.
But with all the dirt stuck to the side plates of the chain, the jockey wheels, and to some lesser extent, the chain rings, I decided a full clean-up is in order. My estimate is that I have probably less than 125 miles on this lubricant so far. That's not a lot of miles, but then again, the test conditions on the final ride before this update were, as I said, severe.
Test Results:
Images of the drive train and Touch-Test:
First off, apologies for the out-of-focus finger! But I think it is easy to see the rollers are free from gunk, but barely! The rest of the chain is pretty dirty, especially between the side plates. I decided to try wiping down the chain with a cloth and brushing the inner chain bits with a dry, clean brush. The following image is the result of this activity:
I also brushed off the cassette, peeled a layer of gunk off the jockey wheels, and I brushed and wiped down the chain rings. I think you can see here that this looks a lot better. In fact, I could run the chain like this. It felt slick, but Pedros does recommend a second coating, if desired, after the initial application. By the way, this all took less time to do than taking the chain off, cleaning it, and dipping it in a wax pot, by far. No comparison there.
So, I have done this, and we will test on from here.
So Far:
I'm not impressed with how things have gone so far. There was more dirt accumulation than I would have expected, especially between the side plates of the chain. The jockey wheel gunk was also not welcomed. I've had better results with other chain lube products in severe dust conditions.
I was hoping to find this lube would push the SILCA Super Secret v1 in terms of results, but this is not the case. The SILCA v2 jury is still out, so I will wait to give my final thoughts on that lube until later.
I think this lube has promise, and I still feel it may redeem itself after getting a cure/dried coating which this lube struggled to do at first. I think this is where all the gunk/dirt accumulation came from. But we will see after this second coating. So, while I am a little disappointed so far, I feel this situation may improve now going forward.



















