Showing posts with label SRAM NX. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SRAM NX. Show all posts

Friday, June 15, 2018

Friday News And Views

NX Eagle- "Ease Of Entry" Component group, or just cheap?
Entry Level, Cheap, Budget Priced 1 X 12:

SRAM predictably dropped the quality of materials and manufacturing techniques enough that a full price range of Eagle components are now available. SRAM apparently is trying to spin the new NX Eagle as being an "ease of entry" group, but let's face it- it's a cheaper Eagle. Call it "budget", entry level, or whatever, but doing some new way of saying "this is the cheapest level" is kind of goofy. We get it- it costs less for a reason.

Now, don't get me wrong, I am not bagging on SRAM, or NX Eagle. I just don't think their "marketing-speak" is genuine. The parts should be awesome. I've been thrashing 11 speed NX for two straight Winters on my Ti Muk and I see no reason why NX Eagle wouldn't be pretty much the same experience. It is what it is, so do not expect the most crisp, fastest shifting, great looking parts, or the lightest weights. You won't get that at this little amount of money. (You can buy the entire NX Eagle group for less than a top end Eagle Power Dome cassette.) What you will get is a good, yeoman's performance for a decent price.

To my way of thinking, Eagle only makes sense if you haven't already gone 1X, and/or if you need the range this group can give you. It isn't as good as the GX Eagle or above, because NX doesn't have the 10T fast cog. It fits Shimano cassette bodies though, so it can retrofit to older non-SRAMed rear wheels. So, on one hand, that could be a benefit to this, or it could be a bummer if ya gotta have that 10T cog.

Purrrrrrple!

My favorite color is purple. This happened to come about for me when I was young. I lived on a highway and it was the zenith of the muscle car era. I saw them all- Chevelles, Novas, GTO's, Road Runners, 'Cudas, Challengers, and Mustangs. Even the rare Daytona would come zooming by once in awhile.

Well, the Chrysler Corporation ran these special colors on their muscle cars like "Slime Lime", "Hemi Orange", and who could forget "Plum Crazy". Those purple machines were my favorites, and that matched up with my early love of the Vikings football team. But they let me down big time in '68. That's another story........

Of course, the 90's were famous for anodized colors and purple was the king of that for a while. I had a 1996 Bontrager Race which was Plum colored, a darker hue, with a yellow panel with red lettering. I had Paul MotoLite purple brakes, and a purple American Classic seat post on that rig. Yep! I love me some purple ano!  I even had the purple ano Surly hubs, and I still rock a purple Chris King head set on my Ti Muk.

Now Paul Components is going to do another special anodized run of parts and this time they are running with purple. Hmm.......maybe I should get some Purple Klampers for the new BMC MCD rig. We'll see. The thing is that the delivery of these parts isn't until late July/early August. I'd hoped to be done with the build by then. But still. purple ano........ 

These are the 650B Carbon Aon GX wheels, but 700c ones will be here today.
 The Pink Puzzle Update:

Building up a bike from a frame and fork is like piecing together a jig-saw puzzle. You need a LOT of different parts and pieces to make it work, and what makes things worse is that certain things are predetermined and certain things are wide open to interpretation. 

One of the puzzle pieces will arrive today in the form of a wheel set. I have been testing wheels from Irwin Cycling recently on RidingGravel.com and I have been thoroughly impressed to the point that I am buying a 700c set for my Pink Puzzle Build. These wheels feature nice hubs with 3.75° engagement and a super smooth set of bearings. But I am most impressed with how these wheels are precisely molded and that transfers to getting a great seal on the tubeless tires.

I've been beating the snot out of both wheel sets Irwin sent to have reviewed and I haven't killed them, or even put a dint in their "armor", besides a few cosmetic scratches from being plowed through mud holes I normally wouldn't ride through on my own equipment. So, I am thoroughly satisfied that they will hold up and be great wheels for several years.

There will be more updates on the Pink Puzzle Build coming soon....

In the meantime, have a great weekend and Happy Father's Day to those fathers out there!

Friday News And Views

NX Eagle- "Ease Of Entry" Component group, or just cheap?
Entry Level, Cheap, Budget Priced 1 X 12:

SRAM predictably dropped the quality of materials and manufacturing techniques enough that a full price range of Eagle components are now available. SRAM apparently is trying to spin the new NX Eagle as being an "ease of entry" group, but let's face it- it's a cheaper Eagle. Call it "budget", entry level, or whatever, but doing some new way of saying "this is the cheapest level" is kind of goofy. We get it- it costs less for a reason.

Now, don't get me wrong, I am not bagging on SRAM, or NX Eagle. I just don't think their "marketing-speak" is genuine. The parts should be awesome. I've been thrashing 11 speed NX for two straight Winters on my Ti Muk and I see no reason why NX Eagle wouldn't be pretty much the same experience. It is what it is, so do not expect the most crisp, fastest shifting, great looking parts, or the lightest weights. You won't get that at this little amount of money. (You can buy the entire NX Eagle group for less than a top end Eagle Power Dome cassette.) What you will get is a good, yeoman's performance for a decent price.

To my way of thinking, Eagle only makes sense if you haven't already gone 1X, and/or if you need the range this group can give you. It isn't as good as the GX Eagle or above, because NX doesn't have the 10T fast cog. It fits Shimano cassette bodies though, so it can retrofit to older non-SRAMed rear wheels. So, on one hand, that could be a benefit to this, or it could be a bummer if ya gotta have that 10T cog.

Purrrrrrple!

My favorite color is purple. This happened to come about for me when I was young. I lived on a highway and it was the zenith of the muscle car era. I saw them all- Chevelles, Novas, GTO's, Road Runners, 'Cudas, Challengers, and Mustangs. Even the rare Daytona would come zooming by once in awhile.

Well, the Chrysler Corporation ran these special colors on their muscle cars like "Slime Lime", "Hemi Orange", and who could forget "Plum Crazy". Those purple machines were my favorites, and that matched up with my early love of the Vikings football team. But they let me down big time in '68. That's another story........

Of course, the 90's were famous for anodized colors and purple was the king of that for a while. I had a 1996 Bontrager Race which was Plum colored, a darker hue, with a yellow panel with red lettering. I had Paul MotoLite purple brakes, and a purple American Classic seat post on that rig. Yep! I love me some purple ano!  I even had the purple ano Surly hubs, and I still rock a purple Chris King head set on my Ti Muk.

Now Paul Components is going to do another special anodized run of parts and this time they are running with purple. Hmm.......maybe I should get some Purple Klampers for the new BMC MCD rig. We'll see. The thing is that the delivery of these parts isn't until late July/early August. I'd hoped to be done with the build by then. But still. purple ano........ 

These are the 650B Carbon Aon GX wheels, but 700c ones will be here today.
 The Pink Puzzle Update:

Building up a bike from a frame and fork is like piecing together a jig-saw puzzle. You need a LOT of different parts and pieces to make it work, and what makes things worse is that certain things are predetermined and certain things are wide open to interpretation. 

One of the puzzle pieces will arrive today in the form of a wheel set. I have been testing wheels from Irwin Cycling recently on RidingGravel.com and I have been thoroughly impressed to the point that I am buying a 700c set for my Pink Puzzle Build. These wheels feature nice hubs with 3.75° engagement and a super smooth set of bearings. But I am most impressed with how these wheels are precisely molded and that transfers to getting a great seal on the tubeless tires.

I've been beating the snot out of both wheel sets Irwin sent to have reviewed and I haven't killed them, or even put a dint in their "armor", besides a few cosmetic scratches from being plowed through mud holes I normally wouldn't ride through on my own equipment. So, I am thoroughly satisfied that they will hold up and be great wheels for several years.

There will be more updates on the Pink Puzzle Build coming soon....

In the meantime, have a great weekend and Happy Father's Day to those fathers out there!

Friday, November 18, 2016

Friday News And Views

Based upon Gary Cale's T.I.v4 entrance card
This Could Be A Thing:
Trans Iowa has been something that has ended up becoming a lot more than a gravel road race for many of us. Some folks are actually prompted to get creative with the event, which most generally involves the traditional post card entry, but it is not limited to that. The pictured artwork today is based upon just such an example. This was based mostly on a post card sent in for T.I.v4 by Gary Cale.

With Mr. Cale's blessing, I have been allowed to make use of this artwork for a project. In the years since T.I.v5, t-shirts celebrating the event have been produced. Not for every year, but for many of those years, I have seen or I have in my possession t-shirts depicting different T.I. headers or whatnot. In fact, I am pretty sure Mr. Cale sent me a rendition of this image, which I'll have to dig around for.

Earlier this Fall I posted the card Mr. Cale sent in on Facebook and it got a pretty big response.  So, I figured it might prove to be a popular t-shirt with the riders. This image is the plan, as of now, for the t-shirt that every Trans Iowa v13 rider will get that shows up in April. You won't be able to buy these. It will be a gift from Trans Iowa to everyone that manages to toe the line.

Maybe that will motivate y'all to train and make it to Grinnell in April?

Anyway, it is something fun and a good limited edition treasure that will tell the world at large you are a true gravel grinding nutcase. I mean that in the best possible way. Really.

Now, this could change. If I notice a big, negative reaction, I can always go with the header icon from the site. But y'all will have to let me know what ya think. Good? Not good? Indifferent? Hit me with a comment.

Stay tuned for more soon........

Grippy. Shifty. 11 speedy.
Upgrade For The Kid:

I've been slowly dealing with an upgrade for my son's fat bike. I was trying him out on a 2X 10 set up, but this whole front derailleur thing just throws his brain a curve ball. He gets the rear shifter just fine, but he has never really gotten the idea through his head that there is a granny gear and that it can make hills easier. So, why beat a dead horse? There are other ways to get him something that rewards him more than the 2X set up he has now.

So, I've had this XD Driver'ed rear wheel that I just got a GX cassette for, but I need a grip shift style shifter, because that is what the young man prefers. So I hopped online to do some investigative Grip Shifter research. What I found was a bit surprising.

I was under the impression that actual twisty shifterage for 11 speed SRAM cassettes was going to be ultra expensive. I found out that now you can get NX level Grip Shift and so that's the next big purchase for the son's fat bike.

It's all in the name.......well, that and TRACTION ACTION!

That Name:

I need a better rear tire for the Ti Mukluk and I have it narrowed down to two choices. The Bontrager Barbegazi or the Terrene Tires Wazia. As of right now, I think the Wazia looks more like what I am looking for. 

What gives with these weird names though? Barbegazi? Wazia? I know that they both have backgrounds that sorta make sense, but.....really? 

WaaaaaaaaZEEEEaaahhhh! 

It sounds like the exhaust note of a two stroke motorcycle engine at full song to me.  Anyway, besides the odd sounding name, the Wazia looks a bit more friendly from the commuting angle and it looks to have a ton of traction, which would be handy on my varied surface commute in Winter. 

Whatever I choose, I'd better get it done soon. The weather is definitely changing. Winter is making its presence known!  

That's all for this week. get out and ride if you can!

Friday News And Views

Based upon Gary Cale's T.I.v4 entrance card
This Could Be A Thing:
Trans Iowa has been something that has ended up becoming a lot more than a gravel road race for many of us. Some folks are actually prompted to get creative with the event, which most generally involves the traditional post card entry, but it is not limited to that. The pictured artwork today is based upon just such an example. This was based mostly on a post card sent in for T.I.v4 by Gary Cale.

With Mr. Cale's blessing, I have been allowed to make use of this artwork for a project. In the years since T.I.v5, t-shirts celebrating the event have been produced. Not for every year, but for many of those years, I have seen or I have in my possession t-shirts depicting different T.I. headers or whatnot. In fact, I am pretty sure Mr. Cale sent me a rendition of this image, which I'll have to dig around for.

Earlier this Fall I posted the card Mr. Cale sent in on Facebook and it got a pretty big response.  So, I figured it might prove to be a popular t-shirt with the riders. This image is the plan, as of now, for the t-shirt that every Trans Iowa v13 rider will get that shows up in April. You won't be able to buy these. It will be a gift from Trans Iowa to everyone that manages to toe the line.

Maybe that will motivate y'all to train and make it to Grinnell in April?

Anyway, it is something fun and a good limited edition treasure that will tell the world at large you are a true gravel grinding nutcase. I mean that in the best possible way. Really.

Now, this could change. If I notice a big, negative reaction, I can always go with the header icon from the site. But y'all will have to let me know what ya think. Good? Not good? Indifferent? Hit me with a comment.

Stay tuned for more soon........

Grippy. Shifty. 11 speedy.
Upgrade For The Kid:

I've been slowly dealing with an upgrade for my son's fat bike. I was trying him out on a 2X 10 set up, but this whole front derailleur thing just throws his brain a curve ball. He gets the rear shifter just fine, but he has never really gotten the idea through his head that there is a granny gear and that it can make hills easier. So, why beat a dead horse? There are other ways to get him something that rewards him more than the 2X set up he has now.

So, I've had this XD Driver'ed rear wheel that I just got a GX cassette for, but I need a grip shift style shifter, because that is what the young man prefers. So I hopped online to do some investigative Grip Shifter research. What I found was a bit surprising.

I was under the impression that actual twisty shifterage for 11 speed SRAM cassettes was going to be ultra expensive. I found out that now you can get NX level Grip Shift and so that's the next big purchase for the son's fat bike.

It's all in the name.......well, that and TRACTION ACTION!

That Name:

I need a better rear tire for the Ti Mukluk and I have it narrowed down to two choices. The Bontrager Barbegazi or the Terrene Tires Wazia. As of right now, I think the Wazia looks more like what I am looking for. 

What gives with these weird names though? Barbegazi? Wazia? I know that they both have backgrounds that sorta make sense, but.....really? 

WaaaaaaaaZEEEEaaahhhh! 

It sounds like the exhaust note of a two stroke motorcycle engine at full song to me.  Anyway, besides the odd sounding name, the Wazia looks a bit more friendly from the commuting angle and it looks to have a ton of traction, which would be handy on my varied surface commute in Winter. 

Whatever I choose, I'd better get it done soon. The weather is definitely changing. Winter is making its presence known!  

That's all for this week. get out and ride if you can!

Tuesday, October 11, 2016

SRAM NX-1: Impressions

Post Fat Bike Century condition.
NOTE: Large doses of "my opinion" will be handed out in gloppy dollops today. You've been forewarned.....

As many of you know, I have installed the SRAM NX-1 drive train and shifter on my Ti Mukluk. Recently it was flogged on my 100 mile Fat Bike Century ride on gravel roads. This is not a "final verdict" on these parts as I still want to see how the group fares through a Winter's worth of use, but this is a first impression of the group and how it performs for me.

I did do a few shorter rides to break in and fine tune the system before I did my century ride. It didn't take much, since there is only one derailleur, to get tuned into primo performance status. There is a barrel adjuster located at the exit point of the cable from the shifter pod, so adjusting this derailleur on the fly is possible as well, should you need to do that.

The conditions on the ride varied from wet, gritty gravel to dry and pretty dusty. So this was a good test of the system in those specific adverse conditions. There was a tiny bit of rough single track at the very end of the ride so I did get a taste of how stable the system is as well, but otherwise it was all gravel roads with a tiny bit of pavement thrown in.

The heart of the system is undoubtedly the rear derailleur and cassette.
Shifting Performance: I used a non-SRAM chain on this build because I do not trust the longevity of a SRAM 10 or 11 speed chain versus the competition. That said, I saw no compromise in shifting performance versus 1 x 11 systems using SRAM chains I have worked on at the shop. Other than this, the system was all SRAM with the Surly, SRAM approved X-Sync stainless steel chain ring. I've used a higher end SRAM 1X11 system before and this NX stuff is not as fast, nor as crisp shifting in the field as the upper end 1X11 SRAM components. That said, it isn't bad. Just not super snappy or fast. It gets the shifts though, and so if you are not racing, this is still a worthy system. Oh......and far less expensive. 

Under pressure the NX-1 still shifts but the slower nature of the system is amplified over the higher end stuff which still will snap off the shift with a high pitched zing! sound from the chain. This NX stuff doesn't do that, and it is obvious that the shift is a bit laborious. I believe it is because the NX derailleur is not as stiff as the higher end XX-1 and the like. The shifter is really smooth, by the way. The trigger action is easy to initiate and is typical SRAM in an ergonomic sense. Whether that is good or bad is a personal preference issue.

The X-Sync style, SRAM approved 28T Surly ring
Drive Train Stability: While this doesn't cover uses such as rough, rocky single track, or big jumps and moves, I can say that the drive train seems quite stable. As stated, I did have some bumpy single track near the end of my ride and there was nothing negative to report concerning the drive train. So for now, all I can say is that it doesn't seem as though chain drops will be an issue.

I will say that the chain line seems biased toward the higher/smaller cog side of the cassette more. Getting up into the lower gears puts the chain at more of a severe angle, and the lowest two cogs show significantly slower shifting as a result. I blame this on the OD crank set and its offset chain ring mounting scheme in combination with the longer bottom bracket of the Mukluk. Surly says the inner ring mounting position of the OD crank is supposed to be where the middle ring would be on a triple, but it clearly is not lined up with the middle of the NX-1 cassette.

Gearing range for a gravel century on our course called for the fastest cogs to be employed vs the big, low gears.
Gearing Range: Everyone is going to have different needs concerning the gearing range of a 1X11 set up, so this is strictly my opinion based upon my experience and needs. That said, there may be some kernels of knowledge here that you could use.

Clearly, I think it can be agreed that I am not going to be doing big gravel miles a lot with this bike. Maybe I won't ever again, since that is not what I have this bike for. The point is, I could do a gravel century with this gearing set up, and I did. Yes- I was in the smallest four or five cogs almost all day. I did reach into some of those big daddy cogs on the cassette when we traversed the Iowa River Valley, but that was it for low gearing needs.

Now this brings up a simple point. Say that I had the "proper" SRAM NX crank or lets say I had an X-1 type with the removable spider. I could swap rings for a ride like the Fat Bike Century or for an appropriate low cog for a trail breaking fat bike ride. That would "only" require some mechanical work when I wanted to switch up. But......

Again, taking a look at this from a different perspective, let's say that the 1X system existed first. There were no front derailleurs ever before this. Then some whiz-bang company comes up with this idea to mount two rings on a crank set and a chain moving mechanism so you could have a choice. Yeah! Now I don't have to chose a ring before a ride, or be caught out on a ride where I wished I had a bigger or smaller cog for a certain section. Now, wouldn't that be an advantage? 

 So, 1X may be the latest fashion darling of the media and SRAM in particular, but that front derailleur idea is far from dead folks. Furthermore, it is, hands down, a better idea for many. Had I been running the former 2X10 set up I had before, in proper tuned up shape, it would have made for a smarter choice for the Fat Bike Century.

Conclusions: The NX-1 is simpler than a triple to figure out and likely lighter than many double ring set ups. It shifts reasonably well, but it is nothing like the upper end SRAM offerings in 1X11 or 1X12 when it comes to precision and speed. I don't know about longevity yet, but these cogs are stamped steel and the main drive ring is stainless steel, so I am hoping for a Winter's worth of use out of it at the least.

When it comes to details the NX-1 is perhaps a bit suspect. The chain line is going to be compromised more at the extremes due to the larger rear cogs and that even if you get the drive ring in line with the cassette's center cog. The drive ring is going to be a compromise in terms of range and where you end up on the cassette. With a double or triple you can use the Keith Bontrager Rules for shifting and eek out the best possible combination for efficiency and shifting performance. However; that means the rider would have to actually think and use the equipment with skill.

Maybe that's asking too much in these days of ADD folks and innergoogles gaming. Anyway.......

I think NX-1 is the more reasonable choice for 1X11 since you do not have to get a different cassette driver than you already may have, nor is it prohibitively expensive to buy and maintain. Plus, with Shimano doing 1X11 cassettes with wider gearing ranges, the possibility exists to get into a better quality cassette and likely better shifting performance. Basically, there is an upgrade path that doesn't require a new rear free hub and/or a rear wheel. Obviously, a new rear derailleur upgrade path can be had as well. So, for starting out in the 1X11 world, I think NX-1 is really a great option. Just know that if you get into higher end componentry, you will probably not want to return to NX-1 again.

I'll have a long term update on these parts most likely at the end of this coming Winter.

Note- I bought the NX-1 cassette, shifter, and rear derailleur with my own damn money, and that goes for the Surly drive ring and the chain as well. I was not paid nor bribed for this post. So there.......

SRAM NX-1: Impressions

Post Fat Bike Century condition.
NOTE: Large doses of "my opinion" will be handed out in gloppy dollops today. You've been forewarned.....

As many of you know, I have installed the SRAM NX-1 drive train and shifter on my Ti Mukluk. Recently it was flogged on my 100 mile Fat Bike Century ride on gravel roads. This is not a "final verdict" on these parts as I still want to see how the group fares through a Winter's worth of use, but this is a first impression of the group and how it performs for me.

I did do a few shorter rides to break in and fine tune the system before I did my century ride. It didn't take much, since there is only one derailleur, to get tuned into primo performance status. There is a barrel adjuster located at the exit point of the cable from the shifter pod, so adjusting this derailleur on the fly is possible as well, should you need to do that.

The conditions on the ride varied from wet, gritty gravel to dry and pretty dusty. So this was a good test of the system in those specific adverse conditions. There was a tiny bit of rough single track at the very end of the ride so I did get a taste of how stable the system is as well, but otherwise it was all gravel roads with a tiny bit of pavement thrown in.

The heart of the system is undoubtedly the rear derailleur and cassette.
Shifting Performance: I used a non-SRAM chain on this build because I do not trust the longevity of a SRAM 10 or 11 speed chain versus the competition. That said, I saw no compromise in shifting performance versus 1 x 11 systems using SRAM chains I have worked on at the shop. Other than this, the system was all SRAM with the Surly, SRAM approved X-Sync stainless steel chain ring. I've used a higher end SRAM 1X11 system before and this NX stuff is not as fast, nor as crisp shifting in the field as the upper end 1X11 SRAM components. That said, it isn't bad. Just not super snappy or fast. It gets the shifts though, and so if you are not racing, this is still a worthy system. Oh......and far less expensive. 

Under pressure the NX-1 still shifts but the slower nature of the system is amplified over the higher end stuff which still will snap off the shift with a high pitched zing! sound from the chain. This NX stuff doesn't do that, and it is obvious that the shift is a bit laborious. I believe it is because the NX derailleur is not as stiff as the higher end XX-1 and the like. The shifter is really smooth, by the way. The trigger action is easy to initiate and is typical SRAM in an ergonomic sense. Whether that is good or bad is a personal preference issue.

The X-Sync style, SRAM approved 28T Surly ring
Drive Train Stability: While this doesn't cover uses such as rough, rocky single track, or big jumps and moves, I can say that the drive train seems quite stable. As stated, I did have some bumpy single track near the end of my ride and there was nothing negative to report concerning the drive train. So for now, all I can say is that it doesn't seem as though chain drops will be an issue.

I will say that the chain line seems biased toward the higher/smaller cog side of the cassette more. Getting up into the lower gears puts the chain at more of a severe angle, and the lowest two cogs show significantly slower shifting as a result. I blame this on the OD crank set and its offset chain ring mounting scheme in combination with the longer bottom bracket of the Mukluk. Surly says the inner ring mounting position of the OD crank is supposed to be where the middle ring would be on a triple, but it clearly is not lined up with the middle of the NX-1 cassette.

Gearing range for a gravel century on our course called for the fastest cogs to be employed vs the big, low gears.
Gearing Range: Everyone is going to have different needs concerning the gearing range of a 1X11 set up, so this is strictly my opinion based upon my experience and needs. That said, there may be some kernels of knowledge here that you could use.

Clearly, I think it can be agreed that I am not going to be doing big gravel miles a lot with this bike. Maybe I won't ever again, since that is not what I have this bike for. The point is, I could do a gravel century with this gearing set up, and I did. Yes- I was in the smallest four or five cogs almost all day. I did reach into some of those big daddy cogs on the cassette when we traversed the Iowa River Valley, but that was it for low gearing needs.

Now this brings up a simple point. Say that I had the "proper" SRAM NX crank or lets say I had an X-1 type with the removable spider. I could swap rings for a ride like the Fat Bike Century or for an appropriate low cog for a trail breaking fat bike ride. That would "only" require some mechanical work when I wanted to switch up. But......

Again, taking a look at this from a different perspective, let's say that the 1X system existed first. There were no front derailleurs ever before this. Then some whiz-bang company comes up with this idea to mount two rings on a crank set and a chain moving mechanism so you could have a choice. Yeah! Now I don't have to chose a ring before a ride, or be caught out on a ride where I wished I had a bigger or smaller cog for a certain section. Now, wouldn't that be an advantage? 

 So, 1X may be the latest fashion darling of the media and SRAM in particular, but that front derailleur idea is far from dead folks. Furthermore, it is, hands down, a better idea for many. Had I been running the former 2X10 set up I had before, in proper tuned up shape, it would have made for a smarter choice for the Fat Bike Century.

Conclusions: The NX-1 is simpler than a triple to figure out and likely lighter than many double ring set ups. It shifts reasonably well, but it is nothing like the upper end SRAM offerings in 1X11 or 1X12 when it comes to precision and speed. I don't know about longevity yet, but these cogs are stamped steel and the main drive ring is stainless steel, so I am hoping for a Winter's worth of use out of it at the least.

When it comes to details the NX-1 is perhaps a bit suspect. The chain line is going to be compromised more at the extremes due to the larger rear cogs and that even if you get the drive ring in line with the cassette's center cog. The drive ring is going to be a compromise in terms of range and where you end up on the cassette. With a double or triple you can use the Keith Bontrager Rules for shifting and eek out the best possible combination for efficiency and shifting performance. However; that means the rider would have to actually think and use the equipment with skill.

Maybe that's asking too much in these days of ADD folks and innergoogles gaming. Anyway.......

I think NX-1 is the more reasonable choice for 1X11 since you do not have to get a different cassette driver than you already may have, nor is it prohibitively expensive to buy and maintain. Plus, with Shimano doing 1X11 cassettes with wider gearing ranges, the possibility exists to get into a better quality cassette and likely better shifting performance. Basically, there is an upgrade path that doesn't require a new rear free hub and/or a rear wheel. Obviously, a new rear derailleur upgrade path can be had as well. So, for starting out in the 1X11 world, I think NX-1 is really a great option. Just know that if you get into higher end componentry, you will probably not want to return to NX-1 again.

I'll have a long term update on these parts most likely at the end of this coming Winter.

Note- I bought the NX-1 cassette, shifter, and rear derailleur with my own damn money, and that goes for the Surly drive ring and the chain as well. I was not paid nor bribed for this post. So there.......

Tuesday, August 09, 2016

Winter Prep

I pretended I was a meteor and left this crater in the Earth Friday
First......Some catching Up:
 
I'll get to the gist of the post today in a minute, but since I haven't been talking here about the day-to-day stuff, I wanted to get a couple of things out there. Friday after we had copious amounts of rain here I decided to ride the 1X1 to work. In an effort to take a mud puddle at slow speed which was at the bottom of a short but steep embankment, my rear tire cut loose on me. The back end of the bike washed out and down I went.

Hard.

It was a right side hit this time. I fell hard on my hip and my elbow and right hand were kind of stuck out like a kickstand when I fell to the Earth. That was a mess, with mud all stuck on me, but it was my hip that really got me. It hurt a lot. I sat there for several minutes before I got up and gingerly washed off in the very mud puddle I was trying to slow roll and stay out of. Irony. It's what was for breakfast.

Well, that made Friday night a nightmare of sorts. I couldn't breathe right, I couldn't get comfortable, and I was a wreck. Saturday was "tax free" shopping weekend for the kid's school stuff, and I was in no mood or shape to ride. Sunday I took off the bike as well, since I was still not right. Things got a lot better with a regimen of "Vitamin I", water, and rest. By Monday I was at about 80%. So, that's a great lead up to Gravel Worlds in a little less than two weeks, right? Yeah........

Working on the tools of Winter Domination!
So, that all actually segue ways in to what I did over the weekend, which was that I worked on the 1 X 11 conversion of the Ti Muk. This rig originally was a 1 X 10 set up, so I am very familiar with how that works, and this time I wanted lower gearing. I ended up using the same wheel with the Shimano cassette body. So......you may be wondering how I got that big 42T low gear? Well, welcome to SRAM NX folks.

You are going to see a ton of NX stuff on new bikes for 2017. It is far, far cheaper than GX or the premium 1 X 11 or Eagle stuff from SRAM. Plus......you can buy a straight up 11-42 cassette. No, you do not get that ridiculous 10T cassette cog, nor do you need that goofy driver SRAM uses on all the other 1 X mtb stuff. Besides......this is a fat bike. Do I really need a 10T cog? No. I do not.

I decided to go all NX with a derailleur and shifter. All the NX stuff besides the shifter is what you might expect. It is mostly stamped steel and plastic. Sure, there are a few aluminum bits in the derailleur, but this is el-cheapo construction here. It's okay. It wouldn't matter if it was SRAM Eagle, I would roach it in one Winter of use anyway, so why not sacrifice the cheapest option to the Winter roads and trails? Hopefully, it actually lasts one Winter!

The NX rear derailleur and cassette. Same top end design in cheaper materials.  
I left the shifter out of that discussion on purpose. That is because it actually is surprisingly nice for a shifter that costs around $20.00. The inner workings feel crisp and smooth. Far better than a shifter this cheap should feel. The plastic levers are actually a good thing. Winter makes metal cold, and anything you touch on a ride that is metal sucks heat from your body. It may seem like a tiny thing, but plastic levers on shifters are actually a good thing for cold weather riding. Even if I were to go with a GX cassette and deralleur or better, I would use this shifter.

Plastic levers- A Good Thing In Winter.
I have intentionally gone with carbon bars, cork grips and carbon brake levers for this very reason. It all makes a difference when the thermometer dips down around zero degrees. Same goes for my pedals, which are Mesa MP's on this bike.

I have to convert the Blackborow DS over to some items like these yet, but I can tell you it all is a noticeable difference when I go ride the Blackborow. The aluminum bars, rubber grips, and metal pedals, not to mention the aluminum brake lever blades, all feel colder and are making it harder to stay warm than it needs to be. So, the point is that now with the plastic levers on the NX shifter, it is one less contact point with metal in the cold of Winter. Let's hope that these actually work well and hold up in the cold weather once we get there.

The final piece of the puzzle was the Surly chain ring. Surly? Why yes.....Surly. You see, the OD Crank I have uses an old BCD for the chain ring bolts. (That's "bolt circle diameter" for you folks that don't speak "bike mechanic".) So, in order to keep using the crank, I bought the Surly, SRAM approved, wide-narrow toothed chain wheel. It is a 28T chain ring, (the only size Surly offers with the X-Sync tooth profile), and it bolted up to my OD crank perfectly. So, there I was this weekend, all ready with these bits, but no chain! I had not remembered to get an 11 speed chain!

Well, I had the old, 10 speed chain laying there, and it wasn't worn beyond spec yet, although it looks atrocious from the "whatever they use on the roads" stuff I ran it through while commuting last Winter. I figured, why not? So, I slapped it on there and what do you know? It works just peachy. That said, I brought home a proper 11 speed chain to put on there so everything will be new, but that was good to find out. You know. Just in case I am in a pinch and the only thing I can get is a ten speed chain.

Lots more to do here yet before Winter, but this takes me a long ways toward the goal of being ready when the snow flies.

Winter Prep

I pretended I was a meteor and left this crater in the Earth Friday
First......Some catching Up:
 
I'll get to the gist of the post today in a minute, but since I haven't been talking here about the day-to-day stuff, I wanted to get a couple of things out there. Friday after we had copious amounts of rain here I decided to ride the 1X1 to work. In an effort to take a mud puddle at slow speed which was at the bottom of a short but steep embankment, my rear tire cut loose on me. The back end of the bike washed out and down I went.

Hard.

It was a right side hit this time. I fell hard on my hip and my elbow and right hand were kind of stuck out like a kickstand when I fell to the Earth. That was a mess, with mud all stuck on me, but it was my hip that really got me. It hurt a lot. I sat there for several minutes before I got up and gingerly washed off in the very mud puddle I was trying to slow roll and stay out of. Irony. It's what was for breakfast.

Well, that made Friday night a nightmare of sorts. I couldn't breathe right, I couldn't get comfortable, and I was a wreck. Saturday was "tax free" shopping weekend for the kid's school stuff, and I was in no mood or shape to ride. Sunday I took off the bike as well, since I was still not right. Things got a lot better with a regimen of "Vitamin I", water, and rest. By Monday I was at about 80%. So, that's a great lead up to Gravel Worlds in a little less than two weeks, right? Yeah........

Working on the tools of Winter Domination!
So, that all actually segue ways in to what I did over the weekend, which was that I worked on the 1 X 11 conversion of the Ti Muk. This rig originally was a 1 X 10 set up, so I am very familiar with how that works, and this time I wanted lower gearing. I ended up using the same wheel with the Shimano cassette body. So......you may be wondering how I got that big 42T low gear? Well, welcome to SRAM NX folks.

You are going to see a ton of NX stuff on new bikes for 2017. It is far, far cheaper than GX or the premium 1 X 11 or Eagle stuff from SRAM. Plus......you can buy a straight up 11-42 cassette. No, you do not get that ridiculous 10T cassette cog, nor do you need that goofy driver SRAM uses on all the other 1 X mtb stuff. Besides......this is a fat bike. Do I really need a 10T cog? No. I do not.

I decided to go all NX with a derailleur and shifter. All the NX stuff besides the shifter is what you might expect. It is mostly stamped steel and plastic. Sure, there are a few aluminum bits in the derailleur, but this is el-cheapo construction here. It's okay. It wouldn't matter if it was SRAM Eagle, I would roach it in one Winter of use anyway, so why not sacrifice the cheapest option to the Winter roads and trails? Hopefully, it actually lasts one Winter!

The NX rear derailleur and cassette. Same top end design in cheaper materials.  
I left the shifter out of that discussion on purpose. That is because it actually is surprisingly nice for a shifter that costs around $20.00. The inner workings feel crisp and smooth. Far better than a shifter this cheap should feel. The plastic levers are actually a good thing. Winter makes metal cold, and anything you touch on a ride that is metal sucks heat from your body. It may seem like a tiny thing, but plastic levers on shifters are actually a good thing for cold weather riding. Even if I were to go with a GX cassette and deralleur or better, I would use this shifter.

Plastic levers- A Good Thing In Winter.
I have intentionally gone with carbon bars, cork grips and carbon brake levers for this very reason. It all makes a difference when the thermometer dips down around zero degrees. Same goes for my pedals, which are Mesa MP's on this bike.

I have to convert the Blackborow DS over to some items like these yet, but I can tell you it all is a noticeable difference when I go ride the Blackborow. The aluminum bars, rubber grips, and metal pedals, not to mention the aluminum brake lever blades, all feel colder and are making it harder to stay warm than it needs to be. So, the point is that now with the plastic levers on the NX shifter, it is one less contact point with metal in the cold of Winter. Let's hope that these actually work well and hold up in the cold weather once we get there.

The final piece of the puzzle was the Surly chain ring. Surly? Why yes.....Surly. You see, the OD Crank I have uses an old BCD for the chain ring bolts. (That's "bolt circle diameter" for you folks that don't speak "bike mechanic".) So, in order to keep using the crank, I bought the Surly, SRAM approved, wide-narrow toothed chain wheel. It is a 28T chain ring, (the only size Surly offers with the X-Sync tooth profile), and it bolted up to my OD crank perfectly. So, there I was this weekend, all ready with these bits, but no chain! I had not remembered to get an 11 speed chain!

Well, I had the old, 10 speed chain laying there, and it wasn't worn beyond spec yet, although it looks atrocious from the "whatever they use on the roads" stuff I ran it through while commuting last Winter. I figured, why not? So, I slapped it on there and what do you know? It works just peachy. That said, I brought home a proper 11 speed chain to put on there so everything will be new, but that was good to find out. You know. Just in case I am in a pinch and the only thing I can get is a ten speed chain.

Lots more to do here yet before Winter, but this takes me a long ways toward the goal of being ready when the snow flies.

Friday, February 12, 2016

Friday News And Views

SRAM marketing strikes with a new 11 spd cassette that is aimed at 1X riders.
SRAM NX 1 X 11 Parts Announced:

If you've been paying attention for the last few years, you know that SRAM has been pushing its 1 X 11 gearing for mountain bikes quite heavily. I've used it, and it is a fascinating idea that ends up being "just okay", in my opinion. (More on that coming up here.) The biggest issue I, and many others have had, with this format is that (a), it requires a specific free hub body and (b), the cost is outrageous for the cassette. Mostly this is due to the outlandish, wasteful carving of a huge block of steel into a single, 10 cog unit, to which a final, aluminum cog is fitted to. The waste in the material and cost to machine the huge chunk of steel forces SRAM to charge exorbitant prices- anywhere from $260-ish to a bit over $400.00 depending upon where you purchase and what level X-Dome cassette you buy. Compare that to $160-ish for an XTR 11 speed cassette from the UK online dealers, and you can see why xx-1 is a bit of a big bite to chew for riders. That's just the cassette too. You still need a special derailleur, shifter, chain ring, and chain.

The obvious solution was for SRAM to find a way to make the 1 X 11 idea cheaper. They tried the GX platform, which still required an XD free hub, which was riveted together and consists of separately made cogs. However; the barrier of the special wheel was still there. Meanwhile, quietly and in typically sedate Shimano style, the Japanese component giant offered an 11 speed, wide ranging cassette that fit on a standard free hub body. Now, SRAM has announced a cassette which also fits on a standard free hub body dubbed "NX" in response. There actually is a whole suite of 1X parts to go with this. Differences to GX are minor, and the NX crank is almost identical to a GX 1X crank, only made with a different aluminum alloy. To wit: SRAM claims both crank sets weigh in the 680 gram range. Functionally they should be identical. The derailleur is a cheaper version of GX probably with lower level materials, as SRAM is wont to do with their groups.

Shimano's XT 11spd, 11-42 cassette- A SRAM 1X alternative
The big deal here is obviously the cassette, and the ability for OEM bikes to be set up 1X in the Far East, shipped here to North America, and hit a retail price point that should be far more palatable to more budget conscious riders. The NX stuff can arguably be said to be "X-5"-ish quality, which means that the materials and construct of the cassette and components will reflect the $75.00-ish dollar asking price for the cassette aftermarket.

But hold on here. SRAM, by ditching most of their proprietary technology like the XD cassette carrier, X-Dome cassette manufacturing technique, and lowering the materials and construction techniques to almost hybrid bike levels, have put themselves into a playing field where Shimano dominates. Check this out.....

A savvy shopper can source an XT 11 speed 11-42 cassette for under $75.00, which is going to have a far better shifting quality and construction than an NX 11 speed cassette will ever have. No.....I haven't seen an NX cassette, but I have seen and handled a GX cassette, and this NX cassette is one level below that. You have a Shimano cassette for about the same asking price as a lower quality SRAM one, and if you have a Shimano Shadow Plus clutch style rear derailleur, it probably can already handle a 42T cog. Want better shifting quality? The replaceable hangar on a Shadow Plus derailleur can be replaced with a Goat Link from Wolf Tooth components and bang on shifting is at your finger tips. While you're at it, you can grab one of Wolf Tooth's chain rings, slap it on your current crankset, and you have a 1X set up as good if not better than XX-1 at a bit more than maybe a NX set up will cost you. Well.....that is if your rig is 11 speed. Of course, you can easily approximate the same deal in 10 speed for similar amounts of cabbage and have a far better quality set up than NX.

So, a great marketing campaign, a good way to get OE spec, but otherwise, not really all that big of a deal in real terms for the performance minded riders that demand durable, great performing parts. I still think Shimano outperforms this stuff, and that 2 X 11 or 2 X 10 is still a better option for riders. Shimano has front derailleurs dialed, and with a two ring crankset, there is absolutely no way that a 1 X 11 covers the same range of gearing for most technical mountain biking with any appreciable elevation changes. Not only that, but your gearing can have closer ratio jumps between gears, helping to maintain momentum, and cadence speeds don't change all that much, making you more efficient.

Will 1X take over the mtb world? I am rather skeptical of that. Especially when wheel technology and the spaces we have to work in for components is what it is. Does 1X look better? Maybe. Does 1X appeal to the mind as being easier to understand? Most definitely. Is it better for "your motor"? Well, there is the real question, no? I will say that a closer ratio gearing is generally preferred by racing folks, and for a good reason. I think average folk can also benefit for similar reasons, and that's why I am not sold on 1X.

Okay, enough ranting for one day! Have a great weekend and hopefully you can hit some cycling up where you live.

Friday News And Views

SRAM marketing strikes with a new 11 spd cassette that is aimed at 1X riders.
SRAM NX 1 X 11 Parts Announced:

If you've been paying attention for the last few years, you know that SRAM has been pushing its 1 X 11 gearing for mountain bikes quite heavily. I've used it, and it is a fascinating idea that ends up being "just okay", in my opinion. (More on that coming up here.) The biggest issue I, and many others have had, with this format is that (a), it requires a specific free hub body and (b), the cost is outrageous for the cassette. Mostly this is due to the outlandish, wasteful carving of a huge block of steel into a single, 10 cog unit, to which a final, aluminum cog is fitted to. The waste in the material and cost to machine the huge chunk of steel forces SRAM to charge exorbitant prices- anywhere from $260-ish to a bit over $400.00 depending upon where you purchase and what level X-Dome cassette you buy. Compare that to $160-ish for an XTR 11 speed cassette from the UK online dealers, and you can see why xx-1 is a bit of a big bite to chew for riders. That's just the cassette too. You still need a special derailleur, shifter, chain ring, and chain.

The obvious solution was for SRAM to find a way to make the 1 X 11 idea cheaper. They tried the GX platform, which still required an XD free hub, which was riveted together and consists of separately made cogs. However; the barrier of the special wheel was still there. Meanwhile, quietly and in typically sedate Shimano style, the Japanese component giant offered an 11 speed, wide ranging cassette that fit on a standard free hub body. Now, SRAM has announced a cassette which also fits on a standard free hub body dubbed "NX" in response. There actually is a whole suite of 1X parts to go with this. Differences to GX are minor, and the NX crank is almost identical to a GX 1X crank, only made with a different aluminum alloy. To wit: SRAM claims both crank sets weigh in the 680 gram range. Functionally they should be identical. The derailleur is a cheaper version of GX probably with lower level materials, as SRAM is wont to do with their groups.

Shimano's XT 11spd, 11-42 cassette- A SRAM 1X alternative
The big deal here is obviously the cassette, and the ability for OEM bikes to be set up 1X in the Far East, shipped here to North America, and hit a retail price point that should be far more palatable to more budget conscious riders. The NX stuff can arguably be said to be "X-5"-ish quality, which means that the materials and construct of the cassette and components will reflect the $75.00-ish dollar asking price for the cassette aftermarket.

But hold on here. SRAM, by ditching most of their proprietary technology like the XD cassette carrier, X-Dome cassette manufacturing technique, and lowering the materials and construction techniques to almost hybrid bike levels, have put themselves into a playing field where Shimano dominates. Check this out.....

A savvy shopper can source an XT 11 speed 11-42 cassette for under $75.00, which is going to have a far better shifting quality and construction than an NX 11 speed cassette will ever have. No.....I haven't seen an NX cassette, but I have seen and handled a GX cassette, and this NX cassette is one level below that. You have a Shimano cassette for about the same asking price as a lower quality SRAM one, and if you have a Shimano Shadow Plus clutch style rear derailleur, it probably can already handle a 42T cog. Want better shifting quality? The replaceable hangar on a Shadow Plus derailleur can be replaced with a Goat Link from Wolf Tooth components and bang on shifting is at your finger tips. While you're at it, you can grab one of Wolf Tooth's chain rings, slap it on your current crankset, and you have a 1X set up as good if not better than XX-1 at a bit more than maybe a NX set up will cost you. Well.....that is if your rig is 11 speed. Of course, you can easily approximate the same deal in 10 speed for similar amounts of cabbage and have a far better quality set up than NX.

So, a great marketing campaign, a good way to get OE spec, but otherwise, not really all that big of a deal in real terms for the performance minded riders that demand durable, great performing parts. I still think Shimano outperforms this stuff, and that 2 X 11 or 2 X 10 is still a better option for riders. Shimano has front derailleurs dialed, and with a two ring crankset, there is absolutely no way that a 1 X 11 covers the same range of gearing for most technical mountain biking with any appreciable elevation changes. Not only that, but your gearing can have closer ratio jumps between gears, helping to maintain momentum, and cadence speeds don't change all that much, making you more efficient.

Will 1X take over the mtb world? I am rather skeptical of that. Especially when wheel technology and the spaces we have to work in for components is what it is. Does 1X look better? Maybe. Does 1X appeal to the mind as being easier to understand? Most definitely. Is it better for "your motor"? Well, there is the real question, no? I will say that a closer ratio gearing is generally preferred by racing folks, and for a good reason. I think average folk can also benefit for similar reasons, and that's why I am not sold on 1X.

Okay, enough ranting for one day! Have a great weekend and hopefully you can hit some cycling up where you live.