Showing posts with label chain lube. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chain lube. Show all posts

Saturday, August 29, 2026

The Guitar Ted Lube-Off: Final Word On Stan's Dry Lubricant

   NOTICE:  The Guitar Ted 'Lube-Off' is a comparison of different lubrication products for bicycle chains that is undertaken in 'real world' conditions in a set way. Then I compare and contrast the results with past 'Lube-Off' products to see "which one is best for me". This is done for entertainment purposes and the reader should apply their own reasoning and discernment while reading my 'Lube-Off' entries. What works for me may not work for you at all. 

Stan's BioBased Dry Lube was a contender in the 2025 Guitar Ted Lube-Off which was never really concluded. So, I wanted to give some closure to this and report on my very long-term  findings! 

The lube lived on the chain running the Black Mountain Cycles MCD drive train and was doing okay. Obviously gravel riding was paused for the Winter of '25-'26, but when things got warmer again, the MCD came out and was put back into use. 

Then BRAN came calling and I decided to take the MCD on the week-long multi-surface ride. BRAN, in case you are unaware, is a ride through Nebraska which hits an overnight town every day for seven days, ala RAGBRAI. You start in Western Nebraska and travel East. Each day has a gravel route option, but you also get a fair amount of paved riding as well. 

I did apply a new coating of the Stan's BioBased Dry Lubricant just before leaving for Nebraska. The image above shows you what the chain and cassette looked like when I returned back to Iowa afterward. You can see a bit of accumulation of dust/dirt on the chain links and a fine coating of dust on the cassette. 

Results of the "Touch Test" after BRAN

The Touch Test is where I run my finger across the chain rollers on the inside run of the chain and observe whatever residue I see on my finger. Depending on the residue, more stuff on my finger usually means a lower rating from me. 

As you can see, there was a fine coating of dust which came off on my finger. In my estimation, we rode nearly 400 miles that week, so this would be what you'd see after that amount of miles with approximately 60% of that total being off-pavement. 

In my opinion, the chain was in definite need of a reapplication of lubricant after BRAN. It felt dry, not very slick, and there may have been a tiny bit of metal on my finger there, which I found a little concerning. 

Final Verdict On Stan's BioBased Dry Lube: 

At the end of the day, Stan's Dry Lubricant is merely "okay". It certainly isn't 'bad', but there are better lubes out there. The BioBased Dry Lubricant is not a dirt magnet, it does the job, for a little while, and it is easy enough to use. 

I wish Stan's Dry Lube had a longer span between applications. 300- 400 miles isn't a lot. Again, not terrible, but I have had other lubricants go longer between necessary reapplications. The amount of dust/dirt which was sticking on the chain and cassette is about the most I would tolerate. The fine coating on everything was a bit thicker than I'd like to see. However; I will say this was Nebraska dirt, not the Iowa dust I normally test in. So, this may have played a part in my end results.  

Good - not great. That is my final word on the Stan's Dry Lubricant. SILCA's Super-Secret and Effetto Mariposa's Flowerpower Wax still are at the top of the heap as of this writing. 

Coming Soon:

I'll have an update on the SILCA Super-Secret v2 lubricant in a little bit. Testing has been going on and I have some thoughts to share on it so far.

Additionally, the 'super-secret', secret lube under embargo until September 1st is also being tested and I have some thoughts on it as well. I think this should prove to be an interesting product. 

Finally, I will have an update when the 'super-secret, secret lube is revealed which has to do with another product I was recommended to use for the test. Stay tuned for that - again, after September 1st. 

Thursday, August 27, 2026

Weekend Adventure Bike Choice

So this weekend on Saturday I'm supposed to be accompanying N.Y. Roll on a metric century ride starting in Reinbeck. I needed to choose a bike for this adventure. Of course, almost anything I choose out of my stable will work, so the reasons I choose what I do is usually based upon extenuating circumstances. 

In this case, as is common for me, I am testing something for review. This time it is a chain lubricant. (Embargoed until September 1st, so I cannot speak to what it is exactly now) So, since this chain lube is on the pink BMC MCD, I am riding that bike. 

But this bike is a good choice for other reasons. Obviously, I like it. Which may be the only reason I need to ride this bike. Next is the Redshift Sports ShockStop stem. I say it all the time: I really enjoy riding with these stems. They work. I feel better after a ride if I use this stem. I wish Redshift would make a polished silver version because I would immediately put on on my Singular Peregrine Mk4 which has silver components. 

But Redshift doesn't do this as of now. Boo!

The bike is geared right, the tires are 50mm wide Schwalbe G-One Overlands, and it is a comfortable bike for long miles. I know this since it is the bike I used at BRAN this year for a week of multi-surface riding. I have always thought of this bike as the skinny-tire version of a Fargo Gen I. They really are pretty similar to each other. In fact, my set up on this BMC was taken directly from my Fargo Gen I. 

So, the pink BMC it is for the weekend. I just have to spruce it up a bit and it will be good to go.  

Wednesday, January 31, 2024

The Cleaning, Lubricating Post

If you recall earlier this year I made the call that i needed to be doing more referencing to past posts from the nearly 20 years of backlog here. Otherwise I get to thinking I should write about a topic and then I find out later that I had already done a series or several posts on that subject years ago. 

This time I am going to point you back through the fog of time to posts I have written on cleaning your bicycles and lubricating the chain a well. 

The first post I will reference here is the one I posted in 2019 about how I go about cleaning my own bikes. It was.....controversial. As one commenter stated, "... I think only old bike mechanics (who know how not to create more work for themselves) understand your bike cleaning practices."

Maybe so. But if you want the best results with the least amount of collateral damage, this is the way you should go about cleaning your bicycles. It works well for me and has for many years. Another primer for easy home cleaning of bicycles can be found HERE that I wrote as part of my Beginners On Gravel series.

Secondly, that post raised some questions which I answered in a separate post. This time it was how I clean up a drive train while it is all still on the bike. Chain lube practices are also covered here. back then I was a strong DuMonde Tech lubricant advocate, (still am), but these days I've been using a lot of Silca's Super Secret Lube. You can check that post out HERE. 

Questions? Suggestions? Hit me up in the comments. If I get feedback I'll do a follow-up post.